A Thousand Leaves vs. Murray Street?
 

A Thousand Leaves or Murray Street?

thousand leaves is sooo underappreciated

1 K

How I <3 1000 Leaves

What?
How is Murray Street losing!
Murray Street is the best.

this was a tough one.

murray street, by far this album is superior!

I agree.

A thousand leaves...wildflower soul and snare girl

they both suck

i was just listening to ATL yesterday. it has more variety. it's way more experimental. it wins.

Agree. Today, this and Daydream Nation are my favourite SY albums.

One of the hardest decision I've ever had to face. It's childish I know, but honestly, if there ever were two albums equally longed for it would be these two. Still undecided.....

There is no way to decide...they are equal, completely equal in every single way, my passion, and my awe for these records arein total unison.

its pretty even.

i don't like either

not a hard choice. meille feuille

A Thousand Leaves are left to stay and...

m leaves. murray street is quite good at the beginning but goes downhill after karenology.

Well its come to this: nostalgia. For me Murray Street will be the better today. The late night insomniac drives through the ghetto listening to sympathy for the strawberry, spending literally weeks at work listening to this album, the dozens of other reasons I have for this album outweigh the nostalgia I've got for Mille de Feville. Damn its the closest second that you could dream of having.

Thousand Leaves.

the street

a thousand leaves has an experiemental blend that meshes amazingly with their songwriting, which becomes more epic and open-ended here. i love their use of pedals and their structures. a beautiful album.

murray street finds them relying on instrumental sections, yet for the first time, in it's grand majority it's not improvised noise, instead it's carefully constructed clean passages and interplay. it has more an emphasis on that yet, most songs are very song oriented and traditional in a sense.

both albums have a lot more in common than people realize

a thousand leaves..
or, as selkcip put it, meille feuille...

a thousand leaves. it seems to get a lot of criticism but i really like it

whoa, its a dead heat.

Murray Street. I just haven't gotten very into AKL yet. i like Lee's trax though. but in my opinion, Karen(ology/Revisited..?) would win it for murra street if it was just a single.

Murray Street, but it's close.

Live tour-wise it's very close as well, but also Murray Street.

That's a tough choice. Both in my top 3 probably. I'm going to have to go with 1000 leaves though... the sounds are so funky.

Murray Street is totally better than A Thousand Leaves. Karenology is the best song of this decade, and probably the best since Telephasic Workshop (like 6 years?)

Murray Street 9.4
ATL (lol) 7.5

The Empty Page 9.5
Disconnection Notice 7.5
Rain On Tine 9.0
Karenology 10.0
Radical Adults Lick Godhead Style 9.6
Plastic Sun 8.5
Sympathy For The Strawberry 9.0

Could someone upload the extra Japanese track if that's allowed here, please.

Amazing Vote.

I picked ATL.

Murray St.

ATL has never been one of my favs, I like NYC G&F much more than ATL.

Mille-feuille

I can't believe this is even being asked! A Thousand Leaves. DUH!! :)

A Thousand Leaves. It's definitely one of my favorite SY releases.